Most people who come to Tintagel today come looking for King Arthur, but in the Middle Ages the place was probably even better known for its connection with Tristan and Isolde. That connection was not an accident either. A good deal of what you can still see on the island seems to have been put there by Richard, Earl of Cornwall, who was keen to tie himself to the most famous Cornish legends of his day.
The story of Tristan and Isolde grew out of Celtic tales told in Cornwall, Wales, Brittany and Ireland, and was later turned into one of the great romances of medieval Europe. The basic plot is simple enough. King Mark of Cornwall sends his young nephew Tristan over to Ireland to bring back the princess Isolde, who is to be Mark’s bride. On the voyage home, Tristan and Isolde drink a love potion by mistake that had been meant for Isolde and the king, and they fall head over heels in love with each other. The rest of the story is taken up with their attempts to hide the affair, King Mark’s growing suspicions, periods of exile and, of course, a tragic ending.
The legend really took off in the 12th Century when two poets, Béroul and Thomas of Britain, wrote rather different versions of it, and many more followed across Europe. Medieval audiences knew the story well, and because it was set in Cornwall it was very useful to anyone who wanted to make the most of Cornwall’s identity and traditions.
In many versions Tintagel was one of King Mark’s main castles. Other places in Cornwall were linked to the story too, such as Castle Dore near Fowey which Rupert and I have also visited, but Tintagel, perched high above the Atlantic, was always going to be the most dramatic setting. So people were associating Tintagel with Tristan and Isolde long before the Victorian tourists turned up looking for King Arthur.
The man who really cemented this association was Richard of Cornwall, the younger brother of Henry III. He acquired Tintagel in 1233 and built the castle whose ruins you see today. Militarily it made very little sense. It was on an exposed and awkward headland, a long way from anywhere important, and lacked most of what you would expect from a serious fortress of the time.
I think it is far more likely that the castle was built as a statement. Richard was Earl of Cornwall and one of the richest men in Europe, and he had every reason to emphasise his links with Cornwall and its legends. By building at Tintagel, a place already associated with both King Mark and King Arthur, he was effectively writing himself into Cornwall’s heroic past.
Several parts of the castle seem to have been designed with the legend in mind. There was a walled garden, and one of the best known episodes of the story takes place in a garden. King Mark is tipped off that the lovers are going to meet there and hides in a tree to spy on them, but Tristan spots the king’s reflection in a spring and warns Isolde, so they have a perfectly innocent conversation that puts Mark’s mind at rest. Having an actual garden at Tintagel meant that Richard could point to the very spot where it all happened. English Heritage have since decorated the garden with paving slabs telling this part of the story.
Then there is the rock cut tunnel through part of the island. Nobody is quite sure what it was for, but it may well have been meant to evoke the lovers’ cave where Tristan and Isolde hid when they were exiled by King Mark. Whether anyone took it literally hardly matters. The point was that visitors could look at the landscape and see the story in it.
The chapel may have had a part to play as well. In one episode Tristan is captured and asks to pray in a chapel on the clifftop, which only has the one door, and then promptly escapes by leaping out of a window down the cliffs. At Tintagel, Richard’s guests could stand in a real clifftop chapel and imagine the whole scene. They were not just visiting a castle, they were being shown the places where the famous stories had supposedly happened.
This would have been a powerful idea in the 13th Century. Medieval rulers were always keen to link themselves with famous historical or legendary figures, and Richard’s castle turned Tintagel into a sort of monument to Cornwall’s heroic past. The buildings themselves mattered rather less than the stories attached to them.
In the long run, though, King Arthur won out. Geoffrey of Monmouth had already made Tintagel the place where Arthur was conceived, and later generations, especially the Romantic writers and artists of the 18th and 19th Centuries, were far more interested in Arthur than in King Mark and his unfortunate nephew.
But the older story has not completely disappeared. Visitors crossing the new bridge are mostly looking for Arthur, yet the garden, the tunnel and the chapel they find on the island owe at least as much to Tristan and Isolde. It is quite something that people are still coming to Tintagel looking for legendary Cornwall nearly eight hundred years after Richard first had the idea. I think we can say that his plan worked rather well.