I always enjoy looking at old maps of the places Rupert and I visit, and this 19th Century Ordnance Survey map of Tintagel is a particularly good one. The surveyors were not trying to sell anything or promote a legend, they were just walking the ground and writing down what they could see and what the locals told them things were called. But because of that, the map ends up recording the myths and the reality side by side, and it tells you quite a lot about how the Victorians saw the place.
The first thing you notice is that there is no village of Tintagel at all. Instead, the village is called Trevena, which, as I mentioned in my main article, was its name for most of its history. The name Tintagel only appears out on the headland, attached to Tintagel Head and Tintagel Haven, because that is what it originally referred to. It is usually said to come from the Cornish for a fort on a narrow neck of land, which would fit the headland nicely, although I would not want to push the etymology too far. Interestingly, this map was drawn just before the distinction disappeared. The Victorian tourists who came to see King Arthur’s castle wrote home from “Tintagel”, and before long the Post Office adopted the name of the castle for the village too. So the map has caught Trevena just before it lost its name.
The church is a little puzzling too, as the map calls it St. Marcelliana’s rather than St Materiana’s. It is the same saint though, and her name has been spelt all sorts of ways over the centuries including Materiana, Marcelliana and Merteriana. That is not unusual for an obscure saint who was only really remembered in one or two places. Later tradition made her a Welsh princess and a daughter of Vortimer, and some think she is the same person as the Welsh St Madrun, but to be honest nobody really knows. The surveyor presumably just wrote down the version he was given, and it is a reminder that even church dedications were not as fixed as we might think.
Just north of the church, the map simply says “Camp”. The modern map calls the same field an earthwork, and it is the field that Rupert and I wandered around at the start of our walk. In the 1950s graves were uncovered there, along with the remains of an early church and a very early Christian burial ground. The Victorian surveyor obviously knew nothing about that. He saw the banks and ditches and assumed, quite reasonably for the time, that they were the remains of an old military camp. He was wrong about what it was, but he was right that something was there, and it would be another hundred years before anyone found out what. It was also of course these graves that helped inspire J.L. Carr’s A Month in the Country.
Out on the headland itself, the ruins are labelled “King Arthur’s Castle”, with “on site of a Camp” written underneath in smaller letters. The headland as a whole is Tintagel Head and the top of the island is simply “The Island”. By the time of this survey, the ruins had been a magnet for Romantic artists and writers for decades, so it is not surprising that the Arthurian name had become accepted enough to put on an official map. Of course, the castle was actually built in the 13th century by Richard of Cornwall, who was far more interested in associating himself with the legends of Cornwall than in building a serious defensive fortress out on such a remote headland. And the Arthur story he was tapping into owed most of its details to Geoffrey of Monmouth anyway.
Funnily enough, the smaller label, “on site of a Camp”, turns out to be closer to the truth. Beneath Richard’s castle archaeologists have found the remains of an important Dumnonian settlement from the centuries after the Romans left, whose inhabitants were importing wine and pottery from the Mediterranean. Nobody in the 19th Century could have known about that, so I suspect “Camp” was just a general way of saying that something older lay there. The map also marks the Remains of St. Julitta’s Chapel, the Enclosure, the Subterranean Passage and the Springs on the island, and several of these features were probably laid out by Richard to match scenes from the story of Tristan and Isolde, so that he could show his guests the garden, the chapel and the cave from the romance. There is also a “Remains of a Monastery” marked near the vicarage, reflecting the old belief that the island had once been home to a Celtic monastery. Archaeologists now think it was more likely a secular and probably royal site.
So the map really mixes up three things: what the surveyor could see for himself, what he was told by the locals, and things that he could not possibly have known about. A lot has changed since it was drawn. The village has taken the castle’s name, the island has been joined back to the mainland by the new bridge in 2019, and King Arthur now has a bronze stand-in on the island in the shape of the Gallos statue, which most visitors assume is Arthur himself. But I think the map shows how every generation tends to see what it expects to see at Tintagel. The Victorians saw King Arthur’s Castle and an old military camp. It has taken the archaeologists to show that the real history of the place is every bit as interesting as the legends.